Anime Kitty vs Misty Water Koi Dice: Which Set Fits Your Table?
By Foam Brain Games - Plastic and Metal RPG Dice, Enamel Pins, and | Published: 2026-10-16
Category: Comparisons
Compare the Anime Kitty and Misty Water Koi RPG dice sets on theme, price, and table presence to decide which one earns a spot in your dice bag.
Quick answer
Choose the Anime Kitty RPG Dice Set if you want a playful, character-driven set that matches a lighthearted campaign or a cat-themed character. Choose the Misty Water Koi RPG Dice Set if you want a calmer, water-layered look that reads clearly on the table and suits a monk, druid, or serene character. Both are plastic seven-piece polyhedral sets at similar prices, so the real decision is theme and table presence, not performance.
What actually differs between these two sets
Both sets are plastic polyhedral dice aimed at the same job: rolling for Dungeons and Dragons, Pathfinder, Shadowrun, Warhammer, or party games. The Misty Water Koi set stands out because the koi is set inside a die with layers of colored resin, which creates a water-like effect. The Anime Kitty set leans on its character art instead of a layered build. If you want dice that look like a tiny scene, the Koi has the stronger visual hook. If you want dice that look like a mascot, the Kitty wins.
How theme changes table use
Theme matters more than most players expect. A set that matches your character gets reached for first, and it helps new players remember which dice are theirs. The Anime Kitty set fits a rogue, bard, or any character with a playful streak. The Misty Water Koi set fits a calm or nature-linked character, and the layered water effect gives it a slightly more subdued look that will not fight with a busy character sheet. Neither set is better in a mechanical sense; they simply signal different characters.
Price and value at a glance
At catalog prices, the Anime Kitty set is the lower-cost option at USD 11.56, while the Misty Water Koi set is USD 12.24. Both list a comparison price of USD 17.00, so the gap between them is small. If you are buying your first set and want to keep the budget tight, the Kitty leaves a little more room for a second set later. If the layered resin look is the reason you are buying, the Koi is still inexpensive enough to justify. The Fae Mushrooms RPG Dice Set at USD 12.58 is a third option if you want a woodland theme instead.
Trade-offs to weigh before you buy
- Layered resin vs. character art: The Koi set uses layers of colored resin to create a water effect, which gives it depth but also means the look is more about the scene than a single character. The Kitty set puts its character front and center, which reads instantly but has less visual layering. Pick the Koi for atmosphere, the Kitty for personality.
- Price gap: The Kitty set costs USD 11.56 and the Koi set costs USD 12.24 at catalog prices. The difference is small, so do not let it decide for you unless you are buying multiple sets. Choose on theme first; the price difference is minor.
- Table readability: Both sets are plastic and aimed at the same games, but the Koi's layered resin can make the numbers slightly busier to read at a glance than a flat-colored set. The Kitty set's simpler surface tends to be easier to read quickly during combat. If fast number-reading matters most, lean Kitty.
Product facts
- Misty Water Koi RPG Dice Set: This beautiful Koi is set in a die that has layers of colored resin giving the effect of being in water. The layered resin is the main reason to pick this set over a flat-colored one, and it gives the dice a depth that shows up clearly when they sit on the table.
- Anime Kitty RPG Dice Set: Perfect for Role Playing Games like Dungeons and Dragons (D&D), Shadowrun, Pathfinder, Warhammer, fantasy, sci-fi, or party games. The set is built for the same games as the Koi, so you are choosing on looks rather than compatibility.
- Fae Mushrooms RPG Dice Set: Contains: 7 polyhedral dice - D4, D6, D8, D10, D%, D12, D20 dice. If you want a full seven-piece set with a woodland theme, this is the closest alternative to the two sets compared here.
Which set should you buy?
Best for
- Players who want a playful, character-driven set for a bard, rogue, or lighthearted campaign
- Buyers who want the lowest-cost option between these two sets
- New players who want a simple, readable set to start with
Not for
- Players who want dice that look like a scene rather than a mascot
- Buyers who prefer a calmer, nature-linked theme for a druid or monk
- Anyone who wants a metal set with a heavier feel
