Banner Class Pin vs Monster Index Pin: Which to Collect?
By Foam Brain Games - Plastic and Metal RPG Dice, Enamel Pins, and | Published: 2026-10-27
Category: Comparisons
Compare the Banner Class Pin Barbarian and Monster Index Pin HippoGriff to decide which enamel pin collection fits your RPG style. Trade-offs in theme, versatility, and price explained.
Quick answer
Choose the Banner Class Pin Barbarian if you want a classic class-themed pin that pairs with any RPG gear. Pick the Monster Index Pin HippoGriff if you prefer a whimsical creature design that sparks conversation.
Theme and visual appeal
The Banner Class Pin Barbarian is a straightforward class icon pin that fits seamlessly into a traditional RPG aesthetic. It works well with other class-themed accessories and dice sets.
The Monster Index Pin HippoGriff leans into fantasy creature lore with a more playful, unique design. It stands out on a bag or lanyard and invites storytelling.
Price and value
The Banner Class Pin Barbarian is priced at USD 7.10 (down from USD 10.00), making it a budget-friendly entry into a themed collection. The Monster Index Pin HippoGriff costs USD 7.50 (down from USD 10.00), a slight premium for a more niche design.
Both pins are made from durable metal and enamel, so you get the same build quality regardless of your choice.
Banner Class vs Monster Index: trade-offs
- Banner Class Pin Barbarian: Classic class icon design that matches other RPG gear. Best for building a cohesive class-themed collection. If you want a pin that fits a traditional RPG look, this is your pick.
- Monster Index Pin HippoGriff: Whimsical creature design that sparks curiosity. Best for collectors who enjoy unique, story-driven pins. If you prefer pins that are conversation starters, go with this one.
- Price difference: Banner Class Pin costs USD 7.10; Monster Index Pin costs USD 7.50. Both are on sale from USD 10.00. The price gap is small, so let theme guide your decision.
Product facts
- Banner Class Pin - Barbarian: Enamel Pin from our new Banner Class Pin collection. These pins are our own unique design and are made of durable metal and enamel. You get a sturdy, original class icon that can be worn on clothes, bags, or lanyards without worrying about damage.
Banner Class Pin - Barbarian - Monster Index Pin - HippoGriff: Enamel Pin from our Monster Index collection. These pins are our own unique design and are made of durable metal and enamel. The same durable construction but with a more whimsical creature design that makes your collection stand out.
Monster Index Pin - HippoGriff
Which should you collect?
Best for
- RPG players who want a classic class icon to pair with their dice and character sheets
- Collectors building a themed set around a specific class or archetype
Not for
- Collectors who prefer creature-themed pins that stand out from standard class icons
